Spoilers
Choices and Endings in The Wolf Among Us Remastered
The season always reveals the same crime. Georgie killed Faith and Lily. The Crooked Man gave an order Georgie says he misunderstood. Vivian's ribbon was a curse. What you change is the tone of the sheriff and a handful of sentences at the end: how Georgie dies, what happens to the Crooked Man, and whether Bigby follows Nerissa. This guide has no verified remaster-specific choice percentages, so it prints none.
Choice, effect, and whether it lasts
Sources are Gamepressure for episodes 2 through 5, IGN for the early chapters, and Wikipedia for the crime itself.
| Episode | Choice | Effect | Lasts? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pay Faith | No drink at the Trip Trap | This episode |
| 1 | Arrest Dee or the Woodsman | Who leaves in cuffs | The next interrogations |
| 2 | How you question Dee | Snow's reaction | Scene |
| 2 | Stop hitting Beast | Thanks, or a grudge | Their attitude |
| 3 | Which door first | Which evidence survives Bluebeard and which people you meet | Missables, not the ending |
| 3 | Burn or keep the tree | Book entry | Collection |
| 3 | Dum | Kill or spare | Yes |
| 4 | Colin, and later Toad | Farm or stay | Their living situation |
| 4 | Ribbon | No immediate effect | Unstated after that |
| 5 | Georgie | He dies either way | Manner only |
| 5 | Crooked Man | Death, the well, or a cell | Yes; exact sequel import fields not announced |
| 5 | Nerissa | Chase or let her go | The last image, not a confession |
What the ending is actually deciding
Wikipedia's plot summary is the backbone: Faith is Allerleirauh, Lily was glamoured to look like Snow, Crane stole from the town and borrowed from the Crooked Man, and Nerissa admits she warned Georgie and placed Faith's head. Bigby suspects Nerissa is Faith. The creators have treated that last beat as an ending, not a dangling teaser that a guide is allowed to solve.
Telltale confirms that defining choices can carry into the sequel, but does not list every imported field. Do not assume a particular dialogue or sentence has a confirmed sequel payoff. Telltale also says the sequel can ask those questions fresh, so a skipped remaster is not a locked door.
Episode 1: Faith
Open the Episode 1 route and source notes. The choice table above can be filtered by episode.
Episode 2: Smoke and Mirrors
Open the Episode 2 route and source notes. The choice table above can be filtered by episode.
Episode 3: A Crooked Mile
Open the Episode 3 route and source notes. The choice table above can be filtered by episode.
Episode 4: In Sheep's Clothing
Open the Episode 4 route and source notes. The choice table above can be filtered by episode.
Episode 5: Cry Wolf
Open the Episode 5 route and source notes. The choice table above can be filtered by episode.
Questions people actually search
How many endings are there?
One crime, several last scenes. The guides do not number a fixed ending count.
Who is the killer?
Georgie killed Faith and Lily. The Crooked Man is the man who gave the order. Details are on the story page.
Do choices change the sequel?
Telltale says remaster choices can carry in with an account, and that the sequel can also set them at the start.
Sources
Checked 30 Oct 2026.