Episode 4
Episode 4: In Sheep's Clothing Walkthrough
In Sheep's Clothing asks what you do with people who cannot hide. Colin can go to the Farm or stay in the apartment. Toad and TJ face the same kind of order later. Nerissa's ribbon can be tugged, and Gamepressure records no immediate consequence. Lucky Pawn and the butcher can be visited in either order: the rooms change, the outcome does not. The Crooked Man can be threatened or answered calmly. This is also where a new remaster trophy lives, on a toy in the pawn shop.
Rooms and the ribbon
Gamepressure's chapter list is House Call, Past Due, Hard Case, Cut Deep, Piece Together, and Come Knocking. Send Colin to the Farm and the apartment is quiet afterward. Let him stay and he is still there. Neither choice is flagged as the 'good' one. The same shape returns with Toad and Junior.
For Master Librarian, PowerPyx says to visit Lucky Pawn before the butcher and inspect the pin cushion on the right. Its remaster trophy route also says to interact with the suspicious toy at the upper left, then interact again after it moves to a shelf on the right. Both interactions are needed for March of the Wooden Soldier. These precise cleanup steps are from PowerPyx alone; the original Gamepressure guide does not cover the new toy trophy.
| Choice | Reading |
|---|---|
| Colin to the Farm or the apartment | Both continue the case |
| Pull Nerissa's ribbon | No immediate consequence in the guide |
| Pawn shop or butcher first | Different cast, same result |
| Toad and TJ to the Farm | Another exile order |
| Threaten the Crooked Man or stay calm | Tone, then the story continues |
Achievements
Once Upon a Time, There Was a Wolf, Who Ruled the Land, He Was Much Feared, But Soon He Mended His Evil Ways, And All Were Happy, and Master Librarian. Add March of the Wooden Soldier if you touch the toy.
Source scope
The original plot and sequence are cross-checked with the public walkthrough and story sources. Exact branch reactions attributed to Gamepressure are that guide's account. Remaster trophy cleanup instructions attributed to PowerPyx currently have that guide alone as their source. Checked 30 Oct 2026.
Questions people actually search
Should Colin go to the Farm?
The guide treats it as a character choice, not a puzzle with one answer.
Where is the new toy achievement?
PowerPyx says to interact with the toy at the upper left of Lucky Pawn, then again after it moves to the right shelf. This remaster-specific route has one source.
Sources
Checked 30 Oct 2026.